Lectionary Year A
May 5, 2002
1 Peter 3:13-22
(JFC) A. GENRE
This text reminds me of Paul's arguing with himself, re:
salvation for the Jews in
Romans 9-11. 1 Peter seems to be trying to get some sense out of suffering
for the sake of righteousness and suffering for something less than
righteousness, but what might prove to be more popular indoor sport than
even trying to do right. Then, perhaps 2 or even 3 changes of subjects
creep into the argument. They are, of course, a mention of the Christ
event, the reference to Jesus' going to proclaim the gospel to those
disobedient previously and then, the citing Noah and the time of the ark
building. Surely, these changes in subject will prove upon further study
to be relevant to the bigger picture of this pericope. It is anything but
a "simple narrative". It is a complex attempt, maybe in early, rough draft
format, to get at a huge truth of some kind. Let's start now looking for
that bigger picture. There are as many phrases of good news in this
paragraph as there are phrases of response to that gospel. Some of the
response statements caution against improper response and/or emphasize
proper response, e.g., verse 15f's admonition to make defenses with
gentleness and respect. Lots of material here, which can be mostly
catalogued under Gospel and Response.
(JFC) B. PERSONAL INTERACTION
This text resembles 2:22-24, a part of our
lection for the fourth Sunday
of Easter. Is the question with which verse 13 begins this text, as
rhetorical as it appears? Does the term "zelotai" seek to get the attention
of some of those fanatical liberationalists of the first century?
verse 15b begin another topic and therefore warrant a period after the
words, "your hearts", as does the NRSV?
This passage addresses the
maligned & the molested. Who, how, why, when, where were they maligned?
Does this epistle assume we will be maligned? Who does the putting to
shame those who abuse those who engage in good conduct for Christ?
is suffering God's will (verse17)?
Does the first pronoun in verse 19
refer to the Spirit mentioned at the end of verse 18? Are verses 19f
really as interruptory of the text as they seem upon first reading in
English? And, are they speaking to the same subject or different ones?
The study note in Oxford's NRSV Study Bible verses 19f says "may mean that
Christ announced his completed work in the realm of the dead to those who
in Noah's day had been disobedient (compare 4:6)." Is that the only
possibility of interpreting Jesus' going to "prison"? The pronouns
referring to those this pericope addresses are in the plural.
(JFC) C. ORGANIZATION
As a theologian, I find the references to the Christ
Event quite dynamic in
virtually every passage from 1 Peter we've studied since Easter. Yet, in
beginning to sense the plights of those originally addressed by these
paragraphs, I get a sense of what contemporary human predicaments today
these verses might address.
As an organizationalist, I am tempted to
re-arrange these sentences into a logical system, more decipherable by the
modern American intellect. Perhaps by the time we get to a smoother
translation, it will clear up some of the difficult vocabulary and/or
grammar. If I were to try it here, it might read something like this -
Good News = Christ deserves to be sanctified, He suffered & died for us,
His resurrection appeals for good conscience & righteous behavior; therein
we find response = prepare to give account, do it gently & respectfully, do
good, it might be commensurate with God's will, fear not anyone who might
threaten to abuse you, for God's dynamic Sovereignty will win out, as in
the time between Jesus' burial & resurrection concerning those who
| Return to gospel listings | Return to epistle listings |
| Return to Old Testament listings | Return to Psalm listings |
| User response form |