Answering machines vs Bezeq's "Voicemail"

which one should I buy?

 Thirteen reasons why you should buy an answerphone - a partial list!
Jonathan Goldstone, who works for one of Israel's  leading companies developing voice mail systems, took exception to some of the items on this list. In particular he mentioned that integrated VM systems deal with faxes in an advanced way, that recording times depend upon the system set-up parameters, and the existence of off-line messaging and unified messaging
I agree with him fully that a well set up integrated voicemail system in an office environment is far better than an answering machine perched on your desk. In particular the ability to send the same voice or data message to multiple users, to send delayed messages, to collect faxes on your office pc, to collect your messages wherever you are etc are great features.
Bezeq however, give you very few, if any of these features, and unlike in the office, at home you are paying each time you use the service.
So at home, I much prefer a digital answering machine with mail boxes etc attached to a fax machine and in the office I prefer a VM system.

1. You can't put a fax machine on a line that has voicemail. Faxes will never get through!
2. You have no visible indication that messages are waiting for you. You need to pick up the phone to listen for the special dialtone and ...........
3. You have to dial in to find out how many messages are stored
4. Voicemail has no monitoring facility. Once the system has answered the call you cannot listen-in (say on Shabbat) and you cannot pick-up the handset and talk to the caller (intercept).
5. You cannot record live phone calls
6. Voicemail doesn't support toll-saver. This is a feature that saves you money when retrieving calls when away from home. With an answerphones you only pay if you actually have a message waiting for you.
7. Voicemail cannot be 'turned off' remotely when away from the house (I'm not sure that it can be turned off when you're in the house either)
8. Voicemail works out more expensive in the long run (assuming your answerphone lasts you more than three years).
9. Messages in voicemail are erased after only a few days so don't go away on holiday for too long!
10. Messages in voicemail are held in some remote telephone exchange where any technician can have a listen. Not very secure. Your answerphone is as secure as your house and any access codes that you have.
11. Voicemail can hold a maximum of 15 minutes worth of messages which is why it erases messages after only a few days.  Answerphones typically have 26 - 60 mins (digital) or as long as the incoming tape (tape-machines.) With a tape machine, you just change the tape and you can save all the old messages for ever!

12. Answerphones have an 'Answer Only' function that allows an outgoing message to be played without accepting incoming messages

13. Modern digital answerphones which cost as little as $20 have multiple mail-boxes so that all the family have their own virtual answering machine.  
 
 

  Return to top
IEC monopoly
Fuse Panel
RCD/GFI
Residential Lighting